"I made the drive from Indianapolis specifically for the sourdough and it was absolutely worth it. The crust had that perfect crackle. The crumb was open and chewy. I bought two loaves and immediately wished I'd bought four."
"Ordered the wedding cake through Wren & Wheat and I'm still getting compliments six months later. Lemon raspberry with Swiss meringue buttercream. The tasting appointment sealed the deal — they clearly care about every detail."
"The almond croissant is genuinely the best pastry I've had in Indiana, and I've tried a lot of them. Flaky, buttery, the almond paste isn't too sweet. I order ahead every Saturday now to guarantee I get one."
"We used Wren & Wheat for our company holiday brunch — 45 people. The bakehouse brunch spread was completely gone in 20 minutes. Everyone asked where the food came from. Effortless to work with and the packaging was beautiful."
"First time visiting — stumbled in on a Saturday drive. Left with a cardamom knot and a half sourdough. By Sunday I was planning my next trip. That cardamom knot is haunting me. It's just cinnamon roll-adjacent enough to be comforting but completely its own thing."
"My daughter's birthday cake was the dark chocolate salted caramel and she said it was the best cake she's ever had. She is twelve and very serious about cake. High praise. Will absolutely be coming back for every special occasion from now on."
"I've been going to Wren & Wheat every Tuesday morning for two years. The staff know my order. The coffee is consistently excellent. The pain au chocolat is something I look forward to all week. It's become the best part of my Tuesday."
"Parking on Saturdays can be a bit of a hunt — get there before 9am or plan to walk a block. Worth it though. The seasonal galette was incredible and the brown butter maple latte is a knockout. Minus one star only because I got there late and the sourdough was sold out."
"Ordered 60 cupcakes for a retirement party. They handled it without blinking. Chocolate salted caramel and lemon raspberry. Every single one was perfect and the batch was consistent. When you order 60 cupcakes you're hoping they all taste the same — they did."
Leave us a review on Google — it genuinely helps more people find us. We read every one and appreciate them more than we can say.
Leave a Google Review